MtG: Peasent Constructed Deck Tourney

Okay, so here's how decklists will work for this tournament.

Usually at a tournament, you turn in a decklist and the judge will glance over it and make sure that there are no glaring errors in it.  ANd then will put it in a stack with all the other decklists.  Sometime during the tournament, you may or may not get deckchecked.  If you have deck errors, then bad things happen (usually a game loss - ouch.)

Reasons why this won't work for this tournament.

1) I'm judging and playing.  This isn't a DCI sanctioned event, but even it if were, judges are now allowed to play in casual rated events.  We're going to use the old 3-judge system.  This means that if you have a judge question, you call me.  If I am playing you that round, then you call Judge 2 (probably Dave or Austin).  If I am playing against Judge 2, and we have a judge question, we call on Judge 3.  This way, no judge is making calls for themself.  

2) Since I'm judging, it would not be fair for me to get to see everyone's decklist but they don't get to see each others.

3) I'm not doing deck checks.  I'm playing.  Plus, this is casual.

So, what we are going to do is this.

1) Make your decklist.

2) Your uncommons need to be listed FIRST.  Every other card in your deck should be common.

3) The only real issue that should come up is if someone thinks you have more than 5 uncommons or some rares.  If this happens, then show your decklist to your opponent, and go over what are common and uncommon.  (If there's a question, then you should probably write down what set that particular card was a common or uncommon in, so that you can prove your point.)  If you cannot resolve it with an "oh, okay" moment, then look at Gatherer and resolve it that way.

4) If it turns out that you had too many uncommons in your deck.  Here's the penalty so that everyone knows -

    A) You keep the first 5 uncommons listed on your decklist.  Any other cards that were uncommons, get replaced with basic land of your choice.

    B) If you happen to have put rares in your deck, these get replaced with basic land of your choice.

    C) You lose the game you are in when the error is discovered.  If you have finished a game, then you receive a loss for the next game you play.  Even if it is against a different opponent.  (DCI penalty guidlines give "Game Loss" as the penalty for illegal decklist at all levels of play.  If possible the penalty is applied in the game being played.  If not possible, then it applied in the next game of the match.)  If it is against a different opponent, then we are using the honor system for you to tell that opponent at the start of the match. 

Peasant Magic is meant to be a CASUAL and FUN format.  

Let's just make sure that we are playing with a legal deck so that we won't have this problem.

Oh.  One more issue of decklists.

At the end of the tournament, anyone who would like to post their decklist on this thread is more than welcome to.  If you won, you can brag.  If you lost, you can talk about what did or did not work for you. 

I'm running another Peasant Magic tourney at WinterWar (Saturday Night), and this might be a good place to try to grow the game in town.

If it is difficult to get numbers for this, you might try starting with Block, Standard or Extended Peasant.  I think that there isn't that large a group of active players with a sufficient collection to really do some of the main Vintage Peasant decks like Burn.

Out of curiousity, where did you dig up this banned list?  Current Peasant information online is notoriously hard to find since most of the old online communities for Peasant haven't been updated in nearly 5 years.  Seems like this banned list hates pretty hard on Affinity.